What a buy 10 get 1 free stamp card costs
Animesh Bhattacharjee, Founding Engineer, RevisitUpdated 4 min read
Key takeaways
- The face value of the reward and its cost to you are different numbers. Use cost.
- A card that needs 10 purchases for 1 free item returns about 9% of spend at face value.
- Two things move the cost: how big the free item is, and how many stamps the card needs.
The headline maths
If a customer buys 10 coffees and the 11th is free, they pay for 10 and get 11. The free coffee is 1 of 11, or about 9.1% of the value they receive. Call it a 9% discount, spread over ten visits.
Shops often print "buy 10 get 1 free" when they mean 10 stamps including the free one. Then it is 1 free in 10, which is 10%. Decide which one you mean, because the card should say so plainly.
Price versus cost
You do not lose the price of the free item. You lose what it costs you to make and serve. The next table is a made-up café example. Use your own numbers.
| Cost to make | Cost of one free item | Cost as a share of 10 purchases |
|---|---|---|
| 30% of price (60 taka) | 60 taka | 3.0% |
| 40% of price (80 taka) | 80 taka | 4.0% |
| 60% of price (120 taka) | 120 taka | 6.0% |
Now compare that with the profit on ten sales. If each sale makes 120 taka of gross profit, ten sales make 1,200. A free item costing 80 taka takes about 6.7% of that profit. The card is cheap when the free item is a high-margin item, such as a drink, and costly when it is a main dish.
What the card has to do to break even
The stamp card pays for itself if customers visit more than they would have. A simple test:
- 01
Find the cost of one reward
Use the cost to make the free item, as above.
- 02
Find the profit on one visit
Average bill times your margin.
- 03
Divide
Reward cost divided by profit per visit gives the number of extra visits the card must create. With an 80 taka reward and 120 taka profit per visit, you need about 0.7 extra visit per reward.
In other words, the card pays for itself if each completed card brings back less than one extra visit that would not have happened. That is a low bar when customers come anyway, and a hard one when they would have come regardless of the card. Your own repeat numbers will tell you more than any rule of thumb.
Ways to cut the cost
- Pick the reward carefully. A drink or a side costs less than a main dish. See reward ideas.
- Lengthen the card. 12 stamps instead of 10 lowers the share to about 8%.
- Start with a head start. Some shops give a first stamp on joining. That is a cost, so count it.
- Watch the reward-claim rate. Many customers never finish a card. Your dashboard shows rewards claimed, so use the real figure, not a guess.
Mistakes to avoid
- Counting the price as the cost, which makes a cheap card look expensive.
- Making the card so long nobody finishes it.
- Changing the rule later without telling customers.
Include the purchase the reward might replace
Suppose your hypothetical cafe spends Tk 45 to make the reward drink. If the customer usually orders a paid drink on that visit, the effect can be larger than the ingredient cost. Estimate how many claims are on an extra visit, how many replace something the customer would have bought, and how many come with another purchase.
Run a low and high case so you can see how much your estimate depends on that mix. On an extra visit where the customer buys a paid snack, include the snack's contribution and the cost of the free drink. On an ordinary visit where the free drink replaces a paid one, account for the revenue you would otherwise have received. The loyalty value calculator guide explains how to keep those assumptions visible.
Is 10 stamps the right number?
It is common, but test it. Cafes with daily visitors often use 8 to 10. Shops with monthly visits use fewer.
Does the free item have to be the same product?
No. A drink for a food card, or a small gift, can cost you less.
How do I know it works?
Compare return visits before and after, using the dashboard's return visits figure.
Want to see how the card looks to a customer? Try the demo, or read how a digital stamp card works.