Digital loyalty card vs loyalty app
Revisit teamUpdated 3 min read
Compare the customer journeys
| Task | Apple Wallet card | Dedicated app |
|---|---|---|
| Join | Open the shop's link and save the supported pass | Install the app and complete its onboarding |
| At checkout | Open the saved pass and show the code | Open the app and navigate to the member screen |
| Before visiting | See card details and follow issuer links | Browse products, place orders or manage a booking if built |
| After an order | See eligible updates to the pass | Use features and notification preferences the business implements |
A coffee shop whose regulars only need to see stamps can test the shorter Wallet journey. A chain that already takes scheduled pickup orders in an app can keep ordering there and add a wallet pass as a quicker checkout surface. Apple's Wallet developer overview
What should the business compare?
List the tasks your customers do each month. Ask which ones must happen directly in the interface and which can use a link to your website. Compare support for Android and iPhone, help with lost phones and the ability to reverse transactions. For an example, see Revisit's wallet cards.
Related reading: Compare wallet loyalty card platforms
Estimate the operating cost of a branded app
Compare year-one costs
For passes, include provider or issuing costs, setup, integration, scanner equipment, training and customer support. For an app, include design, builds and releases, backend operations, maintenance, monitoring, and support. The formats can share order and loyalty infrastructure. Compare the additional cost of each interface over a common baseline.
As an illustration, an existing app could add a member screen for ৳60,000 with ৳5,000 monthly maintenance, for ৳120,000 in the first year. A pass option modeled at ৳15,000 setup plus ৳4,000 monthly would cost ৳63,000 before integration and support. These are assumptions for a spreadsheet, so use your own quotes and feature list.
Which tasks justify an app?
Reordering, delivery tracking and managing bookings can each justify a richer interface if customers use them often. A one-scan membership check can fit a pass. Compare customer completion rates, support cases and ongoing update workload using a wallet card demo or your app prototype. Apple's guide to distributing passes
Related reading: Compare wallet loyalty card platforms
What happens after the first download?
What happens on the first visit?
A customer can open a link or scan a code to add a compatible pass to Wallet. An app usually asks the customer to install and open it first. Ask five customers to join without coaching and record how many complete signup and show their card before leaving the counter. Apple Support on adding passes.
What happens after the fifth visit?
A wallet pass can display current status when its issuer sends a pass update. An app can provide a catalogue, ordering, and account settings, which add value when customers use them. Compare the ongoing work of supporting a pass with the cost of app releases, login recovery and platform maintenance. Apple Developer on Wallet passes.
Build around the useful action
For a takeaway counter that needs a fast stamp and redemption, start by testing a wallet pass and a separate Android path. For a chain already handling regular mobile orders, add rewards to the existing order flow and decide if an optional pass would speed up in-store identification.
Related reading: Loyalty card platforms apple google wallet · Compare app-free loyalty programs